Immunization, part 1 of 2
Another conversation we had, hanging out with my extended family Saturday night, was about immunization. Five of my six brothers’ wives immunize. My mother is fervently against all vaccines, across the board, and my only sister chose not to vaccinate her four kids. (I just texted her to confirm that.) My youngest brother’s wife has no babies yet but is vocal about her plans not to vaccinate.
I don’t talk about this on the site very often, though one of my original posts in Fall ’07 was about my decision not to give my kids any shots. That very old post gets tons of hits, and you may be interested in the comments of parents on that post.
“Outing” myself on this subject, on the internet, is ironic since I was very, very quiet (secretive, even) with friends and family as I had my babies and chose not to immunize them.
Parents everywhere agonize over the decision to immunize or not. Utah has 22-24% non-immunized children, and if you want your child to attend school here, without proof of the entire schedule of shots being completed and signed by a doctor, you have to sign a waiver at the health department. (When you do this, you sometimes get a stern lecture by a nurse.)
I was informed by my children’s pediatric practice, when my 3rd child was a year old, that we were no longer welcome there, because I wasn’t vaccinating according to the APA schedule. My children were “a threat to the other children in our practice,” they said. I was handed my children’s records and shown the door.
I cried all the way home and then wrote Dr. David Johnson (American Fork) an indignant letter. Among other things, it pointed out the logical fallacy of my non-immunized kids being a threat to immunized kids. (Do you believe your vaccines work, or not? If so, there’s no threat.) I also said, “If that’s really your reason to deny my children medical care, you better not take your immunized kids to church, or to school, or to Walmart either. Since a quarter of the kids there aren’t vaccinated.”
I was asked to speak to a large pediatric practice recently, and then they found my views about vaccines and required me to change some language on the site before they agreed to continue with our plans.
I don’t counsel anyone not to give their kids shots. The decision is personal, and it is difficult. What I do is beg you to become informed. Read the “other” side of the issue, and know that your medical doctor likely has been educated exclusively by the vaccine industry (and its dubious research arm).
Please do not consider your medical doctor’s advice the same thing as educating yourself. At the end of the day, your doctor is just one person. A person who got a very specific education. And a very biased education, at that.
Medical practice is now contained and restrained in a huge book of codes allowable by insurance companies. Insurance companies will pay almost exclusively for drugs, surgeries, technology. Not prevention, nutrition, naturopathy, herbal treatments, or anything else outside the standard medical education.
More on this tomorrow.
I think that if a doctor wants to exclude anybody from his/her practice let ‘em. In America, medical practice is a business (at least until ObamaCare takes over). I knew of a doctor who only sees mothers who will breastfeed their babies (when there is no medical excuse not to) because he believes that is in the best interest of health. Keep America free. There are many factors that contribute to disease and also to good health. If people are free to research for themselves, they can make decisions that are pertinent to them. let’s keep it that way and keep learning from each other.
B
Mary, thank you so much for sharing your extensive knowledge on this subject!!! I have two young children, both born at home, and after doing my own research decided not to have them vaccinated. My mom chose not to vaccinate the youngest two of eight children after #6 contracted meningitis just a few short weeks after receiving the HiB vaccine. To be honest, as a young teen I felt her decision was foolish (not knowing any better), but once I found out I was pregnant with my first baby I felt an urge to research the topic on my own.
I am actively still researching and trying to compile my own library of information to have on hand so that I can be better prepared to share with others. I would love to know where you found a lot of your information! I have done a lot of reading on line and have read many article and books but there is so much more information out there. Two resources I find very informative are http://www.drtenpenny.com as well as NVIC. I appreciate the other websites that have been mentioned in other posts and look forward to reading those!
Thank you, Robyn, for your post! It is so nice to know that I am not alone in my decision and that there are so many of you out there who have taken the initiative to get informed. No decision should be made blindly! How many of us do our research before buying a new car, refrigerator, TV, computer, etc., after all we want the best, right? Yet when it comes to the health and well being of our children all too often parents just “go with the flow” and follow the advice of our doctors? Personally my children are FAR more important and valuable than any worldly possession. It is a blessing to have them and therefore my duty responsibility to do whatever I can to keep them safe and healthy!
I am the daughter of a mother who was partially paralyzed by polio 4 years before I was born, and spent her entire life that I knew her on crutches, then in a motorized scooter when she got post-polio syndrome. So, you would think I would be in favor of vaccines. But, I’m not. Vaccines are a bandade to use when we’ve chosen an unhealthy lifestyle. My mother smoked, and was a smoker when she got polio. My mother’s diet was also very unhealthy.
I read in a book (can’t remember for sure which book, but I *think* it was Sugar Blues) that during the polio epidemic, a Dr. in North Carolina found his patients who ate sugar were the ones who got polio. He instructed all his patients to stay away from sugar, and none got polio that summer. Word got around to the community, and people stopped eating sugar — and stopped getting polio. The next year, Coca-cola and the local ice cream company (who were loosing $$) campaigned heavily w/advertisements saying sugar was healthy. People listened to the ads, started eating sugar – and drinking coke and eating ice cream – again, and started getting polio again.
God didn’t create our bodies to be sick. We make ourselves sick with unhealthy choices. That’s been happening since the days of the plagues, when people lived in filthy villages that invited rat infestations, which brought with them the fleas that spread the plague. We need to do our homework and find out how to live healthy and do it!
What a great threaded discussion! I often feel very alone in my choice not to immunize. I left my “I am fine with non-immunized patients” pediatrician after being told that people like me are the reason that whooping cough still exists.
As I was researching vaccines during my pregnancy, one of the most shocking things was the HepB vaccine at BIRTH. That virus can only be contracted through blood to blood contact, sex, or needle sharing — I was very confident in my ability to keep my infant away from those activities.
I work in holistic health and I can say that in 8 years of seeing clients, the healthiest adults I have known are non-immunized. My daughter is now four and has never been sick enough to warrant medication – she has never even had any over the counter meds. We used homeopathics for teething and bumps and bruises. If my husband or I get sick she might exhibit very mild symptoms for a day – but she is so much healthier than other kids her age.
I feel more and more confident with our decision not to vaccinate all the time. I feel sorry for several moms I have met who did not want to vaccinate but did because they were told that they would have to do it to get their kids in daycare or school. One mom shared that she was told that her choice was to follow the schedule now or have to pile them up before sending her child to school. I think that bullying people into vaccinating is just dead wrong. These moms are always so shocked to find out that we have put our daughter in preschool without an immunization record.
I guess the bottom line is that it is up to us to know our rights and research our options. Thanks Robyn for putting this out there – I am sure it will empower many!
Hi Valerie and Bonnie ~
So glad you saw vaccines for what they are which is akin to blood-letting in the middle ages. They talk about lead in toys, and mercury in fish, but no one sees the fallacy of injecting someone, bypassing the normal immune defenses (ears, nose, throat), w/these neuro-toxic heavy metals and carcinogens. Unbelievable how naive and ignorant people are.
I understand a parent’s concern re: these ‘diseases’ or ‘viruses’, but once you uncover the truth about the sole purpose of vaccines which is about $, bottom line, you understand how everything else is designed to make you ‘think’ you need these god-forsaken poisons.
Once you commit yourself to a purpose or solution to a problem, it seems that it becomes easier to identify the answers that are all around us, i.e., through people and our own experiences. I knew this was possibly one of the most important decisions to make and I did not make it lightly. My own grandfather was a medical doctor, although in a holistic sense, and my sister-in-law was a pharmaceutical rep, now pharmacist. I have several cousins who are nurses and/or are in the medical field. So I did not want to make a knee-jerk decision, even though it was assumed that I would vaccinate.
I chose independently not to vaccinate my own children, both of whom were born at home w/o any medical procedures. My son is intact, and I read and talked w/other parents who also had not chosen this barbaric procedure. Neither was vaccinated and are bright, healthy young adults.
I have spent several hundred hours reading, discussing, attending lectures, talking w/health professionals on both ends of the spectrum, and yet w/all this info gathered, my initial decision still rings true not to vaccinate based on the ingredients in vaccines.
You don’t need hundreds of hours of research, but do read as much as you can on both sides to become truly informed and above everything, trust your gut and your instincts.
My friend Ronnie and his wife, Jennifer, a nurse, waited 6 mos. until their baby boy, Eric, received his first set of shots. They were assured by their doctor that vaccines are safe and that there are no side effects. They were not 100% comfortable w/going through on this procedure, however, in the end, they relented. Their son, Eric, once a healthy, bright, bubbly little boy, is now 19 and suffered seizures soon after the vaccines were administered, and has continued to have seizures until this day. He has never walked, talked, sat up by himself, fed himself, etc. He has the body of a 4-yr old child and weighs 44 lbs. This is not an unusual situation in that many other children have suffered as badly as Eric, and some far worse, if you can imagine. It’s just that you don’t see them in public as they cannot function and their parents are exhausted from taking care of them and the rest of the family.
I hear personal stories from parents who tell me they wished they had trusted themselves instead of the doctor, who does not have all the answers, and is often unwilling to share all the data and knowledge re: vaccines. Many of their children now require 24/7 care and they work 2-3 jobs to keep it together w/their other healthy kids falling through the cracks.
Urge others to do their homework too. You could save a life by letting people know that they have a choice. I hand out vaccine info cards by VacLib.org They are $16 for 100 cards and you can order more than that. Just ordered 1000 for $90. I hand them out daily to people; parents I see at the market, post office, schools, etc. My words are, ‘from one parent to another, I thought you might be interested in this important info’ and hand them the card which has over 25 websites on the back side. It’s a great piece of info and I’ve only had a few people say, ‘no thanks’.
Rediculous! If this thought process of not immunizing spreads it won’t be too long until we see a resurgence of diseases such as polio, measles etc. Maybe vaccines aren’t “perfectly” safe but they sure beat having polio! And those who brag about having children who haven’t been immunized and as yet have no “childhood” diseases…You can thank the 75% of parents who choose to immunize their children for that. What a stupid argument! Furthermore does anyone read history? In our not too distant history the Spanish Flu, yes a simple flu, one that could have been prevented with an “evil” vaccine, killed over 25 million people! What about the Native Americans who were almost wiped out because they had no immunity to “white man’s” diseases? Something as simple as a common cold killed thousands.
I don’t know what to do, as a young mom. I have a 4 year old, a 2 year old and a 9 month old. All kiddos have been immunized thus far. I would like to bring another argument to the table. As our government, as inefficient as they are, ruins even more of our health care the ‘immunizations that can save the masses’ will be rationed and delt with as terribly as other government funded programs are handled. Does anyone remember last year? The long lines at the health dept to get the swine flu shots? Hmm…..create situations where lots of parents with small children stand in lines for hours all together…create situations where diseases can spread like wildfire… then turn parents away in the end and not give them the shots after all and make them work at finding it somewhere else just to expose lots of kids and groups of people to each other. STUPID! STUPID GOVERNMENT!
I did not want to stand in those lines. I was a high risk household since I had just given birth and had two young children. The government was in charge of the immunizations, the administration of said vaccines, and the government was the shortage reason. Even rated as a high risk family, we could not get the shots anywhere! Do we really really think that if an epidemic comes out our GOVERNMENT CAN SAVE US? REALLY? Our health is in our own hands and will have to be even more so as government puts their filthy hands all over even more of our health choices! We need to be more health self sufficient regardless if we believe in immunizations or not for ourselves and our loved ones. I, personally, know that those in the alternative medical world have assisted me and empowered me to be more health self sufficient. The mainstream medical community has simply put a bandaid (pill/medication) on my children and me reagarding our health concerns.
Also, I was recently upset last month with my child’s pediatrician because he told me, when my baby’s weight/height chart reflected that he hadn’t grown as much as the curve, “He’s so far advanced. He looks healthy, but start giving him creams and sauces and gravies and you can start on whole milk. He’s already getting lactose through you from your breastmilk” He’s only 9 months old!
Yes, he’s trying to walk already, tackling stairs, and is a smart smart kid (if I do say so myself
) but is his body ready for this? He’s got rolls and chubby cheeks! He was only 18 inches long when he was born! (8 pound 3 ounces chubby bubby yes because I exercise and eat really health when pregant) Genetically I’m only 5’4 and petite and my hubby isn’t that tall either for a guy! I wanted to scream because instead of questioning the nurse’s mesurements (which actually said he shrunk? how is that possible? Especially since I had to bump him up in clothes sizes early because he was busting out of his 6 to 9 month clothes!)
I was advised to give my baby foods I don’t even eat! The same doctor said, at my son’s 2 year appointment, “Don’t stress too much about what your kids eat, as long as they drink milk and take a vitamin. Kid’s don’t really eat vegetables anyway.” Or, at my daughter’s 3 year appointment said, “If she is thirsty give her milk. Milk will quench her thirst and her hunger.” But advises moms to stop breastfeeding at 12 month old because, “Hunger and thirst is what drives babies to eat food. They will decline in weight if you keep breastfeeding past 12 months.” I also heard him tell a drug rep who was still breastfeeding her baby past the 12 months when she got home at night and one time during the night when he woke up, “It isn’t really conforting to the baby to breastfeed past that time just for the mom”. (Then why the heck do mom’s stick pacifiers in their kids mouths if the sucking reflex isn’t a confort reflex? And, why discourage a working mom who feels it is a bonding time for her baby for doing so?) Guess who? Yep. Dr. Weipert.
Thanks Robyn! I feel validated now for my anger after reading your blog tonight. And, as for Dr. Glade, my good friend and neighbor helped initiate him into the ‘alternative medical route’ with her 7 kids and being a herbalist. She challenged him on the immunization/medicine issue and HE LISTENED! Just FYI for the Utah County moms out there.
Ok…I don’t feel validated for my anger…I can validate my own anger (just to correct my thought). I should say that now I don’t feel alone. I have even more motivation to switch. I am, honestly, not trying to smear a person. I am not that kind of person. I am just trying to present the facts as I see them and share my experiences. It is interesting that my path has brought me to the same conclusion as you and another mom, and to your blog tonight. I have been praying for inspiration. I have been wondering where else to go? This has been an answer to my prayers. I am building my courage muscles. I am learning too. Thanks.
Mom of 3,
You seem to have had a similar experience with your pediatrician that I had at my daughters 9 month check-up. I too was told that I needed to feed my baby cream, oils, etc. Not only that but he told me that I must produce low-fat milk because she is not gaining a whole lot of weight….HUH????? I found myself staring at the guy just bewildered at what he just said. Both my kids are average height for their age but below average on the “chart”. They are very happy, healthy and active kids. My youngest has yet to see a doctor for anything other than her checkups and my oldest for constipation (which by-the-way seems to be under control now that I have him on green smoothies and eating more whole grains and less white flour). I could go on about the bad advice this doctor gave me (Dr. Hurley), but the main reason I kept going to him is because he NEVER hassled me about my choice to not vaccinate. Since our last appointment however, I am in search of a new pediatrician. If anyone has any suggestions I would greatly appreciate it!!!
Valerie, most people who read this blog aren’t from Utah Valley, but if you are, my pediatrician for 10 years is Melissa Kendall at Utah Valley Pediatrics. We essentially never see her, but she knows me because I’m rather different than most parents she sees, so I chat with her if I see her at Costco or whatever.
I like her because while she is very mainstream medical, she’s also very respectful of me as a mother. (She’s a mom of 6 herself.) Not only does she not give me grief over my choice not to vaccinate, but when I told her, regarding an ear infection my daughter had when she was a year old, that I was going to try ear candles rather than use the Rx I was offered, “Yes, I know ear candles. I think they work, and here’s why . . . ”
Openminded, fair, and respecting a parent’s right to choose. That’s all I ask for (besides good credentials/experience, of course).
I will keep researching about immunizations. I will read the websites people have posted. This issue has come up with the Chiropractor I have been seeing too and a good friend within this last month. When something is a trend in my life like this, I try to pay attention to what I am trying to be told or taught. I will be more informed about immunizations before I do any more with my kids. I am glad to know that I might get chewed out or kicked out if I take a breather for awhile until I decide what is best for my kids either way. (I would hate to “effect the employee annual bonus” that is based on the % of kids that are vaccinated in a negative way. Did you know that has been an incentive program contest before between offices?). That way I can switch before my next appointments. I still don’t know what to do, but I don’t want to be pressured either way right now. Thanks.
AND..I want to be the one to decide how long to breastfeed my baby!
Thanks for the info moms and for being fair! Moms have to stick together.
The problem I have with this whole discussion is that I don’t really know which research to trust. Both sides have radical claims. Both sides claim their research is accurate and/or scientific.
I am generally not thrilled with conventional medicine and would much rather be treated holistically. I have reluctantly vaccinated my two children (always wondering if I did the right thing) because I believed there was no “perfect” answer. Both sides carried risks. Both sides have compelling arguments as well as “radicals”.
I’m still confused, to be honest.
Darla, many of the studies quoted in the several books I like (O’Shea, Miller, Neustadter) are from Europe and Canada, whose protocols are very different than ours. I decided if 10% of what I’d read was true, injecting dead or “attenuated” bacteria in massive loads (36 vaccines now demanded by the APA!) bypassing my babies’ natural defense systems directly into their bloodstreams, plus a bunch of heavy metals and toxic chemicals, was a very bad idea for my children.
Robyn,
Thanks so much for referring your pediatrician, I will be calling her office tomorrow! By-the-way, my 11 month old had her first taste of green smoothie yesterday and she LOVED it, just spinach, peach, blueberries and a little banana. She is primarily breastfed still and will continue to be so for a while, but I have been slowly introducing solids over the past three months. She wasn’t too interested in them at first so I didn’t push, just a taste or two here and there. I was so excited when she wanted more of the green smoothie though! I made another one today and again, she just wanted more. Both my kids love them. My four year old even prefers that they are more “planty” tasting than fruity, so he gets more greens, sprouts and other veggies. If only I could get my husband on board, he is my picky eater!
Thanks for sharing all you have learned with all of us!
there are risks if I vaccinate – there are risks if I don’t, right now I stopped vaccinating. My children that were vaccinated, and put on antibiotics all the time and fed the SAD are the most unhealthy, but luckily, all my children are healthy. They are trim, fit, etc.
I have been thinking about this same issue quite a bit lately. I vaccinated my 2 older daughters on schedule. One had asthma as a toddler, and still has moderate allergies. My other daughter has had severe problems with strep, and still gets at least 2 cases a year. My 5 year old is extremely behind on his vaccination schedule. We only did a very few. By FAR, he is my healthiest child. He has never had any allergies or strep, or anything else. He has never even thrown up in his life–I kid you not. I have been thinking over the last year, there HAS to be a vaccine connection. He starts school this Fall, and I am unsure how to go the route of getting an exemption or waiver, but I am leaning towards it. How does one go about doing that in Utah county??
Our pediatrician is also Melissa Kendall. We really like her. She is respectful of mother’s choices. I opted to ditch the varicella, and she was supportive.
Love this blog, love all the mom’s comments and hate Dr. Weipert who I have never even met! (I live in canada) Thanks for everyone’s thoughts!
to amom:
Yet, risks of non-vaccinating are far-far less than of vaccinating, I believe. Very often people think of rubella or mumps or others as of something much worse than they are in reality.
The adverse effects of vaccination just pile up with time, leading to God-knows what chronicle problems in our health and lack of immunity overall.
to mom of 3:
why do you put so much trust and energy in going to pediatricians at all? I stopped going to milestone check-ups because I don’t see a point. When we see kids are growing fine- why do we need an affirmation from a doctor? I feel sorry for my friends who spend so much time and energy bringing their children to the doctors. They sit there in waiting rooms together with sick kids, breath in the visures, then wait wait for the doctor to say something like: “Breastfeeding is bad for your babies teeth” and stay upset afterwards.
We need to lurn to trust our own guts and stay informed.
Ninsk, I totally agree. I elected not to subject myself and my last 3 kids to any “well baby” exams. I mean what’s the point of taking a healthy child to a doctor? So he and his misinformed staff can belittle you, pressure you to vaccinate, and make you feel like a bad parent when you know in your heart that you are doing way more and exercising more responsibility than most parents to give your kids better health?
Granted, there is a need for doctors, like when my son broke his arm. But when you’ve chosen not to vaccinate, well child exams are just a waste of time and money. (They along with vaccines are the bread and butter of pediatrics.) The other benefit is not having to worry yourself sick when the doctor points out that your healthy, developing breastfed child is not exactly following a growth chart based on overweight formula fed babies. (No offense moms who have chosen to formula feed–it’s just a fact that they often–not always–grow faster and heavier.)
The best thing I ever did was to stop relying on allopathic doctors to tell me things that my gut tells me is wrong.
One other thing that has become a pet peeve of mine is the use of the word” immunizations” when referring to these toxic injections. There have been many very good studies that call into question the idea that vaccines provide any immunity at all. So let’s call them what they are: vaccines–not immunizations. Even pro-vaccines studies cannot prove they work–they can only suggest a cause and effect.
I work in health care and I assure you, we are not all foaming at the mouth, waiting to take patients’ time, and money – the latter of which we then plan to split with big pharma. .
For ages humans have suffered from debilitating illness. As we evolved into a society no longer throwing rocks at the moon, humans naturally sought to curtail suffering brought on by illness – especially that which strikes the youngest and weakest segment of the population. Medical scientists were able to create immunizations that, if administered properly, spared humans from some of those treacherous illnesses that had previously cycled through populations.
The healthcare professionals I know care about their patients and would never suggest anything they considered harmful. They thoroughly advise on statistics, relevant side-effects, and choices. When an RN, NP, PA, or MD advises, or strongly urges parents to choose inoculation, it is not because they are rubbing their hands together at the thought of all the money they stand to make from payments from big pharma or insurance carriers. Perhaps it is different in Utah or the middle states, but in the urban area in California in which I work, I can’t think of a single doc/RN/PA/NP that accepts gifts of any kind from pharmaceuticals – including cash bonuses. In fact, most have policies AGAINST such activity. The message they wish to convey to parents is that inoculating your children will spare you, them, and the population at large the heartache and burden of polio, whooping cough, and rubella, to name just a few. There are potential risks – these risks, when looked at in a sensible, educated way, are minimal. This is the part that always stumps me – the belief that immunizing places children at higher risk than NOT immunizing. The results of catching and living through some of these childhood diseases are extremely unpleasant. I purposely will not go into detail on this part since people of your belief often accuse people of my belief of using “scare tactics” to sway your opinion to my side.
As for your pediatrician – the issue is not that your school age children are a risk to other school-age children. The issue is that your school-age children, when they walk in that pediatrician’s office may be carrying germs on them will infect infants and toddlers not yet immunized. Your decision to not immunize your children affects the population at large.
As we deal with a pertussis epidemic in California, I’ve come to the conclusion that perhaps it would be best for those of your opinion to live in communities where you may send your children to schools and to doctors (assuming of course, you utilize medical science for anything) with other, like minded individuals. That way, when an outbreak occurs, society at large can easily contain infected individuals and treat them if they/their next of kin choose to proceed in that direction.
Thank you for your green smoothie tips. They are yummy and I drink them for my dose of greens, health, and weight control. I also thank you for your glowing recommendation of the BlendTec Total Blender. I was able to purchase one last summer at a Costco demo and I love, love, love it!!!
I will be unsubscribing to your newsletter and YouTube. I was comfortable with your site when I felt your tips were nutrition and health related (read: not dispensing medical advice – especially on pediatrics) Clearly, I am not a member of your target audience.
I urge all reading this to explore your options. Talk to parents from all views. Keep an open mind – not all MDs, RNs, NPs, and PAs are in bed with pharmaceuticals or brainwashed by a corporate education.
Good Luck and let’s keep children and adults healthy and wise.
Dolores,
Good job with your fantastic nutrition progress, congrats!
You may be unfairly associating me with others with the “foaming at the mouth” idea. I think folks in the medical profession are just like other folks–primarily good, honest, and working hard doing something they believe in. Some of my closest friends are doctors and nurses and medical reps. However, when you really study the history of allopathic medicine it’s hard to miss the ways we have gone awry. That doesn’t mean surgery and drugs are always bad, but I submit that we have become overreliant on them to our detriment.
We keep doubling, and doubling again, the vaccine schedule for infants, and we’re the only country with an adult vaccine schedule, too–that’s a heavy load for our bloodstream to bear of microbes and bacteria and metals and toxins.
The VAERS’ own data suggests that only 10% of actual vaccine reactions are reported, and some estimates are considerably lower than that. I’m sorry you don’t like one of the topics here on the blog, but I can assure you that just because we are discussing a topic you aren’t flexible on, it doesn’t decrease the value of discussions on nutrition.
You and I are urging GSG readers to do the same thing: explore your options.
I believe we vaccinate too much in this country…..
On the other hand I am old enough to have known people while I was growing up who contracted polio because they were not immunized.
We have not fully vaccinated to today’s standards but we have to ours.
I think both sides of the coin have validity and it takes lots of thought to find what is valid and what is not and then, also, what is dangerous to use and/or not to use.
Hi Soulpatch,
Since the 1960′s, 100% of polio cases have been contracted FROM THE VACCINE.
well, they now have a test to test for autism- it’s been proven it is a gene- not caused by vaccines- but it can bring it out if the child has autism.
this is BRAND NEW. i only know because a friend of mine is considered a high risk because of her age & got this brand new test done. pretty interesting. other than that- i do NOT believe in doctors.
I am an RN with many years of experience. I am also an avid complementary alternative medicine advocate. Immunization is extremely personal. I have seen people who have been debilitated with diseases such as polio, sterilized becaused of mumps, brain damange due to meningitis, and disfigured because of measles. I have also seen many children who had allergic reactions to the immunizations (of course those never get reported by the proper medical authorities), and people who have contracted horrible problems who have been vaccinated. The “studies” reported can show bias either way, depending upon how they are chosen to be reported. There are excellent books on the subject of vaccination. One of my favorites is Vaccines, are they really safe & effective by Neil Z. MIller. It gives lots of good information in it. I personally do not believe in vaccines. Does that mean I will put down those who do? Not at all. I recently had the very sad experience of seing a newborn baby placed in the NICU due to vaccines. They still don’t know the level of damage sustained or whether she will make it or not. I think the little ones immune systems are stressed far too early with what they give them now. Are healthy children endangering those who are vaccines? I don’t believe so at all. The vaccine issue is just like anything else…marketing by the government. And anyone who knows anything about markeing or not can realize that proper marketing can sell anthing to anyone. The best way to deal with this is to study it out yourself. Don’t accept stated things by your doctor or medical specialist. Do your own research. Make an invormed decision and then stick with it. My thoughts on quite a controversial subjet.
It has not been proven to be genetic. Some cases yes, but not all. There is absolutely no history of autism or other neurologic disorders in my, or my husbands family but my daughter has autism. This is the case for many families. I chose to stop vaccinating and support my children’s immune systems so it can work the way it was designed to work.
Thanks for this thread! I immunize, and have never had any problem–my babies comfort quickly after the shots, sleep more the first day, and that’s pretty much it. I have 9 healthy kids. But I have a friend with 3 kids who doesn’t immunize, and now I won’t worry for her.
My older sister, with 1 autistic child and 2 Asperger’s syndrome kids, slowed to partial vaccinations when she began hearing about the risks involved, although now the link seems not to exist. That marks the beginning of my education about the risks of vaccinations (Well, I did religiously read the disclosures about each shot my children were given, but that’s well-presented for the pro-vaccine side, to be sure.) My heart goes out to the family of vaccine victims every time I hear of one, and I appreciate the wealth of information provided here for all of us parents–I have already been reading several of the links posted. I am grateful to hear about parents who followed their gut instincts against pediatricians’ advice–I don’t use antibiotics anymore (well, I do use that popular ointment sometimes) after my first son had multiple rounds of it for ear infections. They threw his body way off balance, and I was always treating the cures. He still remembers this after 16 years! Do your research and trust yourself. I now have a pediatrician who will ask my opinion about treatment, and is open about risks involved. So much better than my first one, who always gave such “medical” (read, jargon-ized) answers to my questions, as though truth is too technical for a lowly mom to grasp.
Robyn wrote:
Since the 1960′s, 100% of polio cases have been contracted FROM THE VACCINE.
I wonder if Dolores and health care workers like her are familiar with THIS type of statistics? I guess, not. because it’s inconvenient for them. Keep an open mind, Dolores!
Thanks for the info. I never considered not taking my kids to well baby visits until I started talking about HEALTH related issues. Honestly, I really must say, the most healthy people around me (people who I have started befriending the last 6 months) do not immunize their kids. It really is a noteworthy trend, in my life anyway. The moms, I know, who are the most proactive about their children’s nutrition don’t see doctors very often at all (unless absolutely necessary) and alot of my new friends do not choose vaccines (raw food eaters). They don’t know each other either. They are women I have met independent of one another.
A good friend of mine was recently harmed by the flu vaccine. It was sad for her and her small children. It took away so much of her life and her independence. She has had a long road to recovery.
Another friend of mine could not afford flu vaccines last year for her large family. She said it was their healthiest winter ever.
I still am not sure what to do. My husband is very pro-vaccine. He feels erroring on the side of caution is to vaccinate. I am starting to think that we are a huge biological experiement. If vaccines are effective, why all the boosters? And if a big epidemic broke out of any kind, I don’t think our government could mobilize to save us with vaccines. I’d rather my kids confront an epidemic illness full of vigor, green smoothies, being kefir and yogurt fed, eating mom’s healthy homemade food, sleeping enough and getting enough vitamin D from playing outside daily then rely on entities who does not provide enough vaccines anyway (even IF vaccines are effective???? ..that is the question of the day…).
OK..let me correct a quote from above…Dr. Weipert said, “If your kids are thirsty give them milk to drink. Milk will quench their hunger and thirst. It’s hard to get kids to drink enough water.” he did say “Don’t worry about what your kids eat if they drink milk and take a vitamin. Kids don’t really eat vegetables anyway.” and I did paraphrase, from my recollection, “If you breastfeed past the 12 months your children will move down on the height and weigh chart” (something about the trend)…”Hunger and thirst is what drives them to eat and drink.” That is basically the same as above, but if I catch flack from anyone about my posting (directly or indirectly) from his office, my latter thoughts in this posting are very accurate representations of what was said. So, if it comes back, “I didn’t say that!”…maybe not exactly since I didn’t have a tape recorder, but this is how I remember it.
As for the bonuses, the bonus came from the parent company (IHC) ,from my recollection. It was for all the employees of the office when the immunization rate was above a certain percentage. So, it was like a contest in which everyone in the office worked together to send letters and encourage people to immunize. I don’t think that it was people saying, “how many kids can we hurt to make money?”. I think it was the majority of people thinking it was a win win situation for everyone, “Kids get vaccinated and we get a bonus”. But, I don’t think there would be any love loss from employees of the office if a parent or patient left the practice who did not vaccinate either, because this was a ‘contest’ as it were. I do not know if this is still being continued to date. See… I’m not a radical, but it still doesn’t seem right either way.
Reason would suggest too, if a doctor believes that vaccines work and help form immunity..wouldn’t my immunity from my vaccinations be passed to my baby through breastmilk? Don’t I share my immunity with my baby while breastfeeding? Wouldn’t it make more sense to encourage a mom to breastfeed longer than 12 months suggested by Dr. W for that baby’s protection if faith is placed in the vaccine in the first place? I am sure that Dr. Weipert has seen babies and children die from the diseases he tells us to vaccinate against. So…weaning my baby at 12 months really confused me for the sake of immunity. (Not all of us had moms who breastfed us..I’m setting my own precedents here in many many ways.)
I, personally, have not known a person to die from a disease that kids are commonly immunized against. I’m sure it would be a tragedy to witness. I do know that children still die on Native American reservations from immunizable diseases because of poor sanitation conditions (my source is a National Public Radio Show and a close friend who is a health educator in Colorado). Indian Reservations can be like 3rd world countries in our own back yard. That seems like senseless death too??? Also, what do you say about immigration to the US? Does this expose us to more of the diseases that were in decline phases? Anyone? Anyone?
I question, in general regards to this discussion, when dealing with big industry like insurance companies, the government and drug companies if change can come quickly enough to clean up vaccines. I think the science is sound (it sounds the same to me of what my understanding is of homeopathy…like helps to cure like), but I don’t know if the way the idea is executed (vaccines that are currently available in the way they are commonly dispensed) is safe?
Not going to well baby visits is a new idea for me too. I am switching offices. I will see the new doctor (an MD who practices holistic care too) for the next well baby and well child visits to become aquainted with her. Then, I guess, decide if I want to continue on schedule for well baby visits after our initial aquaintance phase. One step at a time. One step at time.
Having so many of my former held beliefs about what is being a good mom challenged at one time gets overwhelming. I’m realizing I can be the one in the driver’s seat in a whole new way from what formerly I believe in regards to my family’s health. But, I’ve kind of been in a funk this week, to be honest, sorting it all out and searching for new MD. These are big big decisions. It takes an emotional tole on a mom. I know the new doctor I will see offers homepathic vaccines. I’ll ask for info on those too and make an educated decision. So, be kind to those with whom we don’t see eye to eye. We all do our best with what is in front of us at any given time with the knowlege we have.
For those parents wondering about pediatricians who will not hound them for vaccinations, try Family Practitioners. They are less likely to bombard you with lectures for your decisions not to vaccinate since they are not solely pediatricians. One pediatrician did inform me that they are held accountable if parents do choose NOT to vaccinate which is why they push. I received this wise advice (choose a family practice in lue of pediatrics) from a friend and haven’t had a problem since.
I am angry that people people are promoting NOT getting vaccinated and messing with people’s lives. I, like so many of you, fell for the antecdotal evidince that vaccines may be dangerous and are unneccessary. After my chiropracter told me that vaccines are dangerous, I stopped vaccinating my 2-month-old son, Wyatt. When Wyatt was three I found him feverish and out of breath one day. I took him to the ER and doctors did not know what could be wrong with him. Then, one doc asked me if he was immunized and I said no. They found that he was suffering from Hib, a bacteria that causes meningitis, which is swelling of the airway and swelling of the brain tissue. After relying on a breathing tube for several days, Wyatt recovered but with some neurological defects. We could have avoided so much pain if we had just vaccinated him. For heaven’s sake, vaccinate your kids!
Can you Robyn or anyone else point me in the right direction for educating myself about the side-effects/effects of vaccinations.
I have a 4 year old daughter and she has received all up to date immunizations according to the Indiana Health Dept. Which I feel to be unnecessary due to her perfect health until after she receives a shot.
Fever, behavioral changes, weakness, etc are all signs I have seen for up to a week following an immunization. Considering not inocculating before Kindergarten.
Appreciate any sources shared.
Hugo, please read my Book Reviews on the site, and I’ve blogged at length on this topic, if you care to use the Search function. Good luck to you in your research and decision making.