Sourdough starter still good?
I have never had much success with baking 100% whole wheat bread and if I couldn’t do it with yeast I wasn’t sure about my chances with sourdough starter, but I was willing to give it a go! So with a bit of trepidation Iordered some sourdough starter to try making bread without yeast. The second day I had my starter it started to bubble nicely, but I didn’t put it in the fridge because I wanted to make a bigger supply. So, I kept adding more fresh ground wheat and water for the next two days, but now my starter wasn’t bubbling anymore and it had a kind of ‘cheesey’ smell to it. There was also a thin layer of water that would form on top of the wheat mixture,even after I stirred it down. I wondered if maybe my kitchen was too cold because my thermostat read in the mid 70′s. So, I gave up on it yesterday and didn’t add more flour and water, planning to toss it and order some fresh starter to begin again. However, today it looks different and is starting to bubble again. It also doesn’t have a cheesy smell anymore….more of a grainy smell, if that makes sense. Does anyone think I should still try to use this starter? Maybe I was just handling it too much before, or my cold kitchen was slowing down the process??? I would hate to throw it out if it’s still good, but I also don’t want to take a chance of getting sick from bad starter, if that’s possible? I don’t know if baking it would kill any ‘bad’ bacteria.
TIA for your input!
A new starter will bubble right away because the bad bacteria are in control. It takes several days for the yeast to move in and kill off the bad bacteria. You must keep feeding the starter with the w w flour and water each day, after removing at least half of it. Keep it in a warmer place (I use a south exposure windowsill) After about a week you can put it in the fridge to slow the action, or use it in pancakes or something else. Always remember to keep a portion of it for when you want to start feeding it to use it in bread.
In my research on Sourdough. If you let it sit on the counter you need to feed it twice a day. But that’s as much help as I can be. Good luck.
Here is a link to a great whole wheat bread recipe that never fails and is absolutely delicious.
http://marly67.wordpress.com/
I did not know about the ‘bad’ bacteria needing to be killed off by the yeast, so it makes sense now what was happening with my starter, i.e. the cheesy smell. I also did not know I should remove half of the mixture. It did not say anthing about that in the instructions that came with the starter…but they were pretty sparse. I’ve already put the mixture in the fridge, so hopefully it’s okay. I guess I can always start over with some fresh starter and I think this time I’ll get some from Jim Simmons (Original Fast Foods) like Robyn recommended. Thanks also for the link to the WW bread recipe. You make the bread sound so delicious, MaryLou, and I’m always up for trying aother ‘fool proof’ recipe (hopefully this one will be fool proof enough for me!).
Thanks for the comments!
Marisa,
I had the same thing happen to my starter. I persisted for several weeks feeding several times a day before it bubbled up and doubled in size one day. Now this starter is very active and I have had great success in baking with it. The key for me was to keep throwing half away and then feeding it even when things looked very grim!
I got some starter from Jim Simmons and it is working great. I even dehydrated some of my own (low heat) instead of throwing it away just in case I killed mine. In his instructions it said to throw away that water that forms on the top as it is a waste by-product. Also I learned that white flour did not feed the starter, but whole wheat flour worked great.
That liquid is also called hooch. Hooch isn’t bad.
And, sourdough is yeast. It’s just not quite as consistent as the yeast you buy in the little packets.
I think that as long as it doesn’t turn colors and get slimy, you’re on the right track.
Would anyone be willing to share instructions for starting starter? My dehydrated starter didn’t come with any and I have never used it before. Thanks!