Does God want us to eat plant food? . . . part 3 of 4
The LDS (Mormon) scripture known as the “Word of Wisdom” was delivered to Joseph Smith in 1833, at a time when virtually all men were smokers and drinkers, and no one knew those were bad habits. The scripture says it is for the “weak and the weakest of all saints,” and it requires things of believers that few LDS people observe. Most do avoid “wine or strong drink,” which we are told “is not good, neither meet in the sight of your Father.”
Mormons are also good about avoiding tobacco, which is “not for the body, neither for the belly . . . not good for man, but is an herb for bruises and all sick cattle, to be used with judgment and skill.” We’re told “all wholesome herbs God hath ordained for the constitution, nature and use of man–every herb in the season therof, and every fruit in the season therof; all these to be used with prudence and thanksgiving.”
Nowhere does it say to adulterate those foods to eliminate their fiber and make them acidic, full of chemicals and dyes, and toxic to people and animals. And most of my own people, modern Mormons, are grossly negligent with regard to the following counsel. They often rationalize this scripture away by saying that now that we have refrigeration, counsel about eating meat sparingly doesn’t apply:
“Yea, flesh also of beasts and of the fowls of the air, I, the Lord have ordained for the use of man with thanksgiving; nevertheless they are to be used sparingly; And it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used, only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine.”
This scriptural injunction is essentially identical to what science has taught us almost 200 years later. The huge, published body of work now known as the Oxford/Cornell China Project is a 30-year study following 6,500 people. It documents with 8,000 statistically significant correlations that a diet containing only 5 percent animal protein prevents disease, whereas a 20 percent animal protein diet aggressively promotes disease.
Plenty of scriptural support for the use of grains is found throughout the canon of Christian scripture. The idea of soaking and sprouting grain and drying it into bread comes from an apocryphal book of scripture known as The Essene Gospel of Peace that some say is the teachings of Jesus to a congregation of Essenes. The LDS “Word of Wisdom” states, “All grain is ordained for the use of man and of beasts, to be the staff of life, not only for man but for the beasts of the field, and the fowls of heaven, and all wild animals that run or creep on the earth.”
A rising gluten intolerance problem in this generation is likely the sad byproduct of genetically modified grains and not evidence that grains are not nutritious foods for humans.
Oh I’d love to pick your brain about this one. I wonder about the general health of the populace of LDS peoples, once highly regarded due to lower incidences of heart disease and lung disease, now, strangely silent on this claim of health. Is it because of the rise of diabetes millitus and its corresponding heart disease issues? It seems like so much of this is caused by the franken-corn that is feeding the US right now. Hmm…
Don’t worry about the corn, yardsnacker! We won’t be eating tons of corn this year thanks to those levees breaking in Iowa!!! But, on a different note, I don’t think Jesus was a vegetarian. He ate fish with his friends…even after the Resurrection. Scripture says he ate bread and wine in the Last Supper and the Wedding in Cana, so if He drank wine, so can we, no?!
Well, believe it or not, the LDS population is still wildly healthy compared to the general population. The only reason for that is that we do not drink or smoke–and those are pretty big reasons. (On our cruise recently, every other person at our table drank a bottle of wine or three triple Scotches, every night, wow.) This is purely observational, as I have no statistics to back this up, but I think we eat as much meat and processed food as anybody, and we suffer from obesity rates here in Utah comparable to national averages.
Christ ate fish, but I bet it wasn’t full of mercury. About wine – there is a big controversy over whether it was fermented wine or not. See what Billy Graham said: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,945726,00.html
He’s not the only one. Many scholars don’t think that the wine that christ drank was the kind to cause intoxication.
Noah got drunk after the floods, Lot got drunk and impregnated his daughter…must I go on? If you read scripture, Jesus partied with taxcollectors. Do you think they drank water? He converted water into wine, and the guests at Wedding at Cana wondered why the hosts served the best wine for last! I can relate, can’t you?!
Your time.com link isn’t a good one. No one can rightly say with certainty that Christ never drank a drop of good wine. And, besides, would you care if Jesus got drunk at least once in His life? Who’s to say that he didn’t drink it socially only?! Nobody.
Robyn, I like this blog series. (I’m a born-again, spirit filled Christian.)
greengirl, the Bible speaks against drunkenness, not against drinking wine. Jesus drank wine (I believe it to be the same wine that we know), so it is okay to drink it. Jesus didn’t get drunk, because that is sin and He is without sin. If you want to drink in moderation, you would be doing as Jesus did.
Some religious groups choose not to drink alcohol at all (Mormon’s), other’s freely allow it (Lutheran’s). I chose not to drink, but I understand from the Bible that it is fine to do so in moderation – that is you may drink, but not to the point where you don’t have control of your body, the Temple where Jesus resides.
If we apply the principal in 1 Corinthians 8:13, (regarding eating of meat that was offered to idols, being a stumbling block to some) we should not drink alcohol (at all or just in their presence) as we would be tempting them to sin, because drinking is a sin for them, in their mind. We need to make our own decision about that one.
From a Spiritual/Biblical perspective, it is fine to drink wine, the Bible is pretty clear on that. But from a health perspective, do we want to be putting even small amounts of “poison” into our bodies? It is a poison, because in large enough amounts it will kill you. Hmmm…. similar with another poison…. processed and modified foods (of which wine is one). Which we are all reading this blog to overcome that poison.
(Well, I certainly needed to hear that one from myself!)
Thanks for all you are doing Robyn! You have really helped me on the path to providing better nourishment for my Temple.
Heidi,
Just wanted to clarify that the “wine” drunk by Jesus is the same wine we drink today. I never said He got drunk. I don’t believe in people saying that wine back then was grape juice.
Im not sure about this, most people don’t give me a straight answer. Is green tea against the word of wisdom? I heard if it is herbal it is okay. I dont like pop, so i started drinking arizona green tea, it is all natural plus 100% vit c and antioxidants. can someone tell me straight so i make the right choice.
Kirk,
I’m not sure if you were asking Robyn, but here’s my understanding. The ‘tea’ that is prohibited by President Young’s interpretation of the word of wisdom (where he interpreted ‘hot drinks’ to mean ‘coffee and tea’), is anything made from the tea plant, Camellia sinensis. This would include any temperature green, black, white, or oolong tea. Herbal tea is an infusion made from any plant other than Camellia sinensis.
Of course you still have to use logic. Should you make an infusion from leaves of the marijuana plant? Probably not. What about yerba mate (contains stimulant xanthines), Brigham Tea/Ma-Huang (contains ephedrine alkaloids), etc.? I feel like we should probably avoid those. I have purchased yerba mate before, but never got around to using that. I know a lot of LDS people do use those. But I think they’re kind of getting off on a technicality, since those herbs are not specifically mentioned in the Word of Wisdom, and aren’t specifically known as stimulants by most average people.
You’re so cool, Katie.
–Robyn