Who you gonna call: Part V Really expensive candy that won’t make you healthy
Moving on to the Xocai chocolate people: they have a great sales pitch!
They show the ORAC score of cacao (chocolate), and it’s way impressive. Right up there with goji berries. I like to use a little raw cacao for that very reason, in my recipes. But, my friends . . . that network-marketed chocolate is $60 A POUND! Do the math–I kid you not.
And eating chocolate bars isn’t the answer, anyway. If you want to eat a little, go to your health food store and look at the ORGANIC, naturally sweetened, high-cacao chocolate bars there. At most, I’ve seen Green & Black’s chocolate at $10/lb.–and usually it’s on sale for less. (The network-marketed Xocai stuff is NOT organic, NOT raw, NOT fair-trade, and not as high in cacao content as most varieties of Green & Black’s.) Be smart and plow your food dollars into logical choices. Eating a $1 bite of Xocai’s chocolate daily will save you from nothing. Feed one bite of that (sugar sweetened) chocolate, three times a day, to a family of six, and you’ll spend $600/mo. That’s my whole grocery budget.
At the presentation I attended, a woman who sells the product said, “I’m so excited about this, because I could NEVER get my daughter to eat a fruit or vegetable, but I can mix this chocolate powder into the frosting on her cupcake and feel really good about her nutrition for the day.” In the world of nutrition, there is no quick fix that can be mixed into frosting.
Here’s the thing about network marketing. The products are going to cost 800 percent of COGS (cost of goods), minimum. I know this because I consulted to a company taking its product into that channel, and I attended the annual conference with all the compensation plan writers, lawyers, and many other consultants.
They all put on their best show to all the would-be multi-level-marketers, and they all said the same thing: “Don’t even bother taking your company into network marketing unless you can mark your product up 800 percent.” That’s a necessity when 8 people get paid commissions on every sale, AND the company needs its profit. It’s simple math, even though network marketers will write me saying “you get what you pay for” and all that.
Please don’t be offended if your career is in multi-level marketing: it’s a valid job done by hard-working people. I give my readers this opinion only because your food dollars are better spent elsewhere. And of course, other products marketed using other methods can be a big waste of money, too. But today’s topic focuses on MLM because people really fall for these products. That’s because the salespeople are so zealous and known to the customer.
My readers are always writing me saying they can’t afford good food–and then I find out they’re spending $100/mo. on massively overpriced supplements. Remember, my opinion hasn’t been bought and paid for by anybody. Take it or leave it, but the GreenSmoothieGirl agenda is this and always will be: helping families get great nutrition and sift through confusion in the nutrition world.
Hi Robyn, excellent post and wonderful blog. I read through several posts and it is clear you love what you do. I also like your contrarian views on wellness.
The points you make should be carefully weighed by anyone looking at Xocai or network marketing in general. I am relatively new to network marketing and a brand new Xocai distributor. Ultimately, Xocai will succeed or fail based on its economic merits, whether its improves the lives of those that buy it at a price they are willing to pay.
As it pertains to how multi-level commissions affect pricing your readers might want to review the following link: http://www.firstclassmlm.com/2007/12/11/do-levels-of-commission-in-mlm-add-to-the-price-of-the-product/
This web site is independent of any network marketing company and is educational in nature.
Finally, the Xocai products are more expensive than what you will find in grocery stores and health food stores but competitive with other gourmet chocolate products. Xocai also contains Açai and Blueberries. Can you elaborate on your “artificially sweetened” comment? The Xoçai Nuggets are considered a “Clean Product”: No Artificial Colors, No Artificial Flavors, No Preservatives, and No Sucralose. I won’t blather on about the other virtues of the product unless asked. *s*
John
Lakeland, Florida
Hi John,
In response to your comment, I have changed “artificially sweetened” in my blog to “sugar sweetened,” since some people (probably not my readers, but the U.S. government) call sugar or cane juice crystals “natural.”
Xocai nuggets contain a tiny bit of acai and blueberry extract, yes. I don’t believe that warrants the $60/lb. price tag, but consumers will make their own decisions. On this site, obviously I am advocating for less purchasing of expensive “extracts” and more purchasing of $4/lb. blueberries. You get much more benefit from the whole food in the packaging God intended for it: all the fiber and synergistic complement of micronutrients.
I bought a box of the Xocai product last year for an experiment. It was a 30-day supply–for $100, I had a bite of chocolate three times a day. After that, I ate Green & Black organic chocolate for several more weeks. I didn’t change anything else in my diet/routine.
Before and after my experiment, I was tested on the Bioscan, which tells you the carotenoid antioxidant levels in the skin, the endpoints of the body. I have studied that technology extensively and believe it to be a good indicator of the OVERALL antioxidant levels in the entire body.
After about 8 weeks eating chocolate daily as Xocai prescribes, my antioxidants went DOWN, not UP. (My reading started way above the 99th percentile and ended way above the 99th percentile. But the number was lower.) This suggests to me that my former diet was very adequate and the chocolate likely did nothing that eating whole plant foods can’t do.
It was a fun experiment, though. I love chocolate.
Robyn
Fantastic post. Very informative.
where to buy acai…
acai is certainly one of the most effective health supplements…
Thanks for your review. I enjoyed reading it! I have been pressured beyond belief to join Xocai from friends in the company. I have bought several boxes of the chocolate and paid $120 each time. The last time I bought the box, the rep said I really needed to sign up so I can get a lower price because she could no longer give me her special rate of $120/box. Her sponser said I was underpaying and should at least be paying $160/box and be grateful to do so. It was then that I did some research on the product. My husband was alarmed at the $60/pound price! When you see it like that, it feels foolish to buy this product! I appreciate you breaking it down like you have and agree that buying the blueberries is a much better way to get the antioxidants!
Robyn, I am looking for fair trade info about Xocai, and discovered that they write that the chocolate is 100% ethically traded from the Ivory Coast and the acai is from a co-op of sustainable practices. in the Amazon. Do you have different info? I see you mention that it is not fair-trade chocolate…wondered if that was a guess or a fact (since Ivory Coast is generally not FT) I would appreciate your input. Thanks, Jean (I am not part of that MLM)
Hi,
I have sold Xocai some time ago and it works, but in my opinion its way too expensive !
I asked myself how much I would spend if I bought pure Cacao and Acai and it made me see that Xocai is extreme expensive and don’t work as good as pure cacao, acai.
I will never order Xocai again and think that the price is a scandal compared with what you can buy from example herb.com. I regret spending so much money on Xocai and people should not have to use so much money to be healthy.
And in my opinion there is so much more than cacao and acai. I recommend use spiraling, Omega 3,6,9 and hemp protein powder.
No more Xocai for me!!!